Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC: A Double-Edged Sword of Difficulty and Praise
Despite critical acclaim and a high Metacritic score, Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC has received mixed player reviews on Steam, primarily due to difficulty and performance concerns across PC and consoles.
A Challenging Experience, Perhaps Too Much So?
While lauded for its challenging gameplay, many players find the DLC's combat excessively difficult and unbalanced compared to the base game. Steam reviews highlight concerns about poorly designed enemy placement and bosses with excessively high health pools.
Related Video
Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree - Falling Short of Expectations?
Performance Issues Plague the Expansion
Performance problems further compound the negative feedback. PC players report frequent crashes, micro-stuttering, and frame rate limitations, even on high-end systems. Frame rates below 30 FPS in crowded areas significantly impact gameplay. Similar frame rate drops during intense moments have been reported on PlayStation consoles.
Mixed Reception Across Platforms
As of Monday, Steam shows a "Mixed" overall rating for Shadow of the Erdtree, with 36% negative reviews. Metacritic presents a more positive, "Generally Favorable" rating of 8.3/10 based on 570 user scores. Game8 offers a significantly higher rating of 94/100. This disparity highlights the divergence in player experience.
The conflicting reviews underscore the intense challenge presented by Shadow of the Erdtree. While some appreciate the demanding gameplay, others find it frustrating and poorly optimized. The performance issues further detract from the overall experience, leaving many players with a less-than-stellar impression of the highly anticipated DLC.
